The Brownstone, Paterson: The One Decision That Governs Everything

These rooms are staged. Photograph the staging, or photograph past it — but choose.

At a large urban banquet venue there is one decision that governs the photographic day, and it is about attitude rather than technique.

Rooms like this are staged. They are designed to produce an occasion: elaborate plasterwork or panelling, chandeliers, drapery, mirrored surfaces, coloured uplighting, and lighting cues that change through the evening. Nothing about them is neutral, and none of it was arranged with a camera’s white balance in mind.

The decision is whether to photograph that staging as the subject, or to work past it and make pictures of the people in spite of it.

Photographing the staging means embracing the warmth, the colour and the theatre: exposing for the room so the fittings hold their structure, letting the walls be whatever colour the uplighting makes them, and building frames around symmetry, reflection and the architecture. That produces a set of pictures that look unmistakably like a celebration in a grand room, which is what it is.

Working past it means using a longer lens, closer framing and controlled light, so that the frames are about faces and the room becomes a soft warm suggestion behind them. That produces a set of pictures that could be at a different venue but are about the people.

Both are legitimate and a good day usually contains some of each. What fails is neither — drifting through the evening taking whatever the room gives, which produces frames that are flat, inconsistent in colour, and neither about the room nor about the people.

We have not photographed a wedding at the Brownstone; large urban banquet venues behave consistently. Which rooms are included, whether the lighting can be dimmed or set for particular moments, whether more than one event runs on a date, what the actual timings are, and what daylight reaches the preparation rooms are questions for their team.

Brownstone at a glance

Where	A large urban banquet venue at Paterson, northern New Jersey
The decision	Photograph the room’s theatre, or work past it to the people
The room	Elaborate, warm, mirrored and uplit — nothing about it is neutral
The failure	Doing neither, and drifting through the evening
Ask first	Rooms included, lighting cues and dimming, timings, other events

If you photograph the room

Photographing the room means letting it be what it is, and it has four requirements.

The first is the exposure, and it is the reversal that makes or breaks every frame in an elaborate room. Expose the ambient for the fittings rather than for the faces — deliberately a stop or a stop and a half under what skin needs — so chandeliers hold their crystal and their individual lamps rather than fusing to white, and so the plasterwork keeps the shadow that makes it read as three-dimensional.

Then add one source for the faces: off the camera axis, at about a stop above what the ambient gives the skin, gelled warm to match the room, and diffused so it does not read as flash. The white balance goes to the gel.

The instinct to raise sensitivity until the room looks bright is what produces the characteristic bad picture of a venue like this: flat, uniformly orange, no depth, and every table identical. The reversal prevents it.

The second requirement is symmetry. Elaborate rooms are built about axes — a chandelier on centre, matching pilasters, a symmetrical head table, a mirrored wall — which means the camera has one correct position and everything approximate reads as a mistake. Square and level, on the axis, checked rather than assumed.

Symmetry is also the frame’s strongest resource. A wide symmetrical frame of a full room, level and centred, is a genuinely impressive picture and it is what such a room is for. It only works if it is exact.

The third requirement is handling the colour rather than correcting it. Coloured uplighting washes the walls, which is the room’s intended look — and it also means light bouncing onto the backs of heads and shoulders is that colour. The rule is to decide which light lands on the face, set the white balance for that, and let the walls be whatever they are. Correct skin with coloured walls is a picture; skin rendered pink or blue is not, and it is not recoverable.

Where the uplighting changes through the evening — and at a venue with lighting cues it will — the white balance has to be checked again rather than set once.

The fourth requirement is using the reflective surfaces deliberately. Mirrored walls, polished floors and glass double every fitting and every figure, which gives symmetry and depth that nothing else provides — and they also reflect the photographer, the equipment and the service doors. A few degrees of camera angle is the difference between the two outcomes, and it is worth finding at the start rather than discovering in the pictures.

A polished dance floor in particular is the venue’s best single resource: a couple reflected in it during a first dance, with the room’s lighting doubled around them, is the strongest frame these rooms give.

Two technical constraints apply throughout. A tall ornate ceiling is not a usable bounce surface — a flash aimed five or six metres up returns almost nothing and what returns is coloured by whatever is painted or gilded there — so a pale nearby wall or a modifier is the working approach. And nothing in a large room bounces usefully, which means the added light has to travel with the subject: a source at two metres needs roughly a quarter of the output of the same source at four.

If you work past it

Working past the room means making the people the subject and letting the venue be a warm blur behind them, and it takes three things.

The first is a longer lens used close. At a longer focal length and a wider aperture the room’s detail dissolves into tone and colour, which means the chandeliers become soft points of warm light and the plasterwork becomes texture. That removes every problem the room presents in one move — no symmetry to respect, no fittings to preserve, no uplighting to negotiate.

The second is a controlled source, and here it does a different job from the one above. Rather than lifting faces to sit inside the room’s exposure, it dominates them — set a stop or more above the ambient on the face, gelled to whatever is dominant, so the skin is rendered entirely by your light and the room contributes only the background.

That is the reliable way to get consistent skin tone across an evening in which the venue’s lighting is changing. It is also the approach that produces a coherent set of pictures rather than one that shifts colour from frame to frame.

The third is finding the dark, which in an elaborate warm room is less obvious than in a plain one but not difficult. A doorway to an unlit space, a corridor receding away, drapery, a dark panel, the space behind a lit table — any of those two or three stops below the subject gives separation, and a frame built on one reads as a portrait rather than as a snapshot in a busy room.

The moments that suit this approach are the ones that are about people anyway: a first look, speeches, a parent’s face during a toast, hands, a quiet exchange at the edge of a room. Those frames are better made close and lit deliberately than wide and ambient.

The rest of the property supports whichever approach is chosen.

The preparation rooms are worth assessing for one thing: whether there is a usable window. Where there is, a subject a metre from the glass turned about forty-five degrees to it gets horizontal light with steep fall-off behind — the best light in any building of this kind — with the room lights off and a custom white balance set on the face. Where there is not, the hour is a lighting exercise: one source through a modifier placed to one side, with the room’s own light a stop under, which gives window-like light and stays consistent.

A grand stair, if there is one, is the best position in the building on either approach: height without equipment, a frame on both sides, and a subject on a different level from everyone else. The light usually comes from above, so a subject looking up the stair catches it in the eyes and one looking down is in their own shadow.

Outdoors, an urban venue gives urban resources. A street is a canyon, so the light on the pavement depends on which way it runs and how high the buildings are — an east-west street is lit along its length at the ends of the day and a north-south one only near the middle, and two minutes with a map tells you which.

Doorways, recessed entrances and solid awnings are the midday shade, and a city has them in quantity. A venue’s own porte-cochère is frequently the best exterior position on the site: a horizontal band of light, a dark surround, no dappling, and an architectural frame — at any hour in any weather.

And after dark the venue’s own lit façade is a large soft source on its own forecourt, which means a couple standing outside in the evening is lit by the building. A tripod, a few seconds and a close gelled source on the faces, and wet pavement after rain doubles all of it — which makes a rainy evening in a city a strong condition rather than a setback.

• Choose the approach and commit; drifting between them fails
• Photographing the room: expose a stop under, one gelled source above skin
• Working past it: longer lens, closer framing, your light dominant on the face
• Set white balance by what lands on the face — and reset it when cues change
• Use the polished floor deliberately; it is the best resource in the room

The northern New Jersey year

A large urban banquet venue is among the most weather-independent in this guide, which means the season affects the outdoor half of the day and the preparation-room light rather than whether anything works.

Winter is cold with snow in most years, and for this kind of building it is close to irrelevant — the honest argument for a February date, and a strong one. Guests arrive under cover and the whole event happens inside.

Where winter helps is twofold. The December sun at this latitude reaches only about twenty-six degrees above the horizon, which means it enters any window almost horizontally and travels much further into a room than a high summer sun does — so a preparation room with a window is better lit in January than in June.

And winter’s early evening is a real advantage at a venue with a fixed running order: the after-dark exterior frames, with the façade lit from within, are available from mid-afternoon rather than after eight, which means they fit inside the schedule rather than falling outside it.

Snow is the outdoor asset — the best natural fill available, lifting every shadow and throwing light upward into faces — and snow against a dark urban façade gives the widest brightness range on the site: expose for the snow and let the building go dark, overexposing deliberately relative to the meter, which snow fools by about two stops.

The costs are cold, a short day, batteries draining faster, and a cold camera fogging when carried from a winter street into a heated ballroom. At a venue with a large temperature difference that is worth planning for: spares in an inside pocket and bodies bagged until they warm.

Early spring is the weakest outdoor part of the year in this region: bare street trees, grey ground and wet footing. Indoors it makes no difference at all, which at a venue built entirely around its interiors is no loss.

Late spring is mild and green, with street planting softening the urban frames considerably through May. The complication is the long days: in June the good low light arrives after eight in the evening, which at a venue with a fixed portrait slot means the best exterior light falls after the reception has started.

That is worth negotiating in advance — most venues will allow a short trip outside during the evening, and it is much easier agreed beforehand than asked for on the night.

Summer is hot and humid — commonly upper eighties Fahrenheit and above with high humidity — with afternoon thunderstorms a real feature from June into August. Indoors none of that matters; outdoors it means the middle of the day belongs to doorways and awnings rather than open pavement.

The humidity also softens any long city view and reduces the definition on masonry, which is the opposite of what an ornate exterior wants.

Autumn is the best season for the outdoor half and the most convenient for a scheduled venue. The humidity breaks in September, the air reaches its clearest of the year, and street and park trees in northern New Jersey turn from the middle of October into early November.

City planting is chosen deliberately and tends to be present in quantity, which means the colour is concentrated rather than scattered — and against a dark ornate façade it reads at full saturation. The scheduling advantage is that the days are short enough for the good light to fall inside a normal afternoon slot rather than hours after it, which at a venue running to a clock is the real argument for an October date.

More frames from Brownstone

Brownstone wedding photography: common questions

What is the governing decision?

Whether to photograph the room’s staging as the subject, or to work past it with a longer lens and controlled light so the pictures are about the people.

What happens if I do neither?

Frames that are flat, inconsistent in colour, and neither about the room nor about the people. That is the most common outcome at venues like this.

How do I expose an elaborate room?

A stop or a stop and a half under what skin needs, so the chandeliers hold their crystal and the plasterwork keeps its shadow. Then add one source for the faces.

How do I handle coloured uplighting?

Set the white balance for what lands on the face and let the walls be their colour — and reset it when the lighting cues change through the evening.

What is the best resource in the room?

The polished floor. A couple reflected in it during a first dance, with the lighting doubled around them, is the strongest frame these rooms give.

When is the exterior best?

Mid-October into early November, and in winter — when the early evening puts the lit-façade frames inside a normal running order rather than after eight.

More New Jersey venue guides

We are writing a photographer’s guide to every venue we would happily shoot in New Jersey. Here are three more, plus the full index:

• Crystal Plaza, Livingston: One Frame, and How It Is Made
• Estate at Florentine Gardens, River Vale: What It Suits and What It Does Not
• The Fiesta, Wood-Ridge: The Problem, and Four Ways Out

All New Jersey →

Planning a wedding at Brownstone?

Its theatre or your portrait — choose and commit. Tell us your date.

Tell us about your day →  |  See recent work